Such a nuanced question as it will depend on many things. Some of these things won’t even have anything to do with the home, like Location, Location, Location. For example, one of the original Longmont Colorado homes around Main Street may always be worth more than a new build on the outskirts because the land it sits on is valuable. When it comes to the actual home it will depend on the location but also the condition. You will also want to consider the age of the mechanical systems such as the air conditioner and plumbing. If the older home has had no recent updates, then a new home may be a better choice.